Politics...

Written by Rutger

Like many other Latin American countries, Nicaragua also had its share of internal and external conflict in the (late) 20th century (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaragua#History). Politics therefore is a sensitive subject in Nicaragua and I found out that a lot of people here have strong feelings for a certain party and/or against the other (rival) party. If you go into the field here around Matagalpa you’ll see flags, colors, and others signs of the different political parties everywhere. People make it easy to see what party they vote for, and graffiti on walls either advertises for one party or  tries to put the other party in bad daylight. To a certain extend that is ok, I think, and it should be fine to stand for what you vote for in an open democracy, but not if it goes too far. Not if you do not accept the people who vote for the other party, and especially not if being members of different parties stands in the way of working together for the greater good. It gets even worse when poor people, who have nothing to do with a dispute between two parties, are victims of this lack of cooperation. I was very surprised to see an example of this happening here in Nicaragua:

One of the projects the WFP has in Nicaragua is helping pregnant women, lactating women, and kids in the age between 6 and 36 months by supplying them with extra food. The WFP calls this project “Grupos Vulnerables” (Vulnerable Groups, GV), because these women and children are most vulnerable in case of food insecurity. Part of our work is monitoring the distribution of this food, and make sure that the food reaches the right people. While a colleague and I were monitoring for GV in a village in quite a remote area, we noticed that there were six boxes of oil missing. That is 6*12=72 bottles of oil that the Vulnerable Groups, as mentioned above, would not receive. After some research we found out that the oil never reached the village and that the oil must have been “lost” (probably stolen) during transport. That is where the problem started.

It seemed that the MINSA (Ministry of Health) and the municipality had a shared responsibility for the transport. The problem was that the doctor of the MINSA told us that it was the responsibility of the municipality, and that the Mayer of the municipality told us it was the responsibility of the MINSA. Both parties did not want to take responsibility for the missing oil. One of them, or both, had to take responsibility and repay the oil, so we asked them to get together and discuss the matter. To my surprise, they did not want to. Apparently the doctor did not want to talk or to be seen with the Mayer and Mayer did not want to talk or to be seen with the doctor. And why? We found out that it was because they are members of the two rival parties, that’s why.

I was flabbergasted when I heard that. 72 bottles of oil (a lot and very important for people who have nothing) would not reach poor people in need, because two well educated adults don’t want to get together to discuss the simplest of matters and come to a solution, just because they are members of two different political parties. Why is it so difficult for grown up men to set aside political feelings when peoples wellbeings are at stake? I didn’t expect such a thing in Nicaragua, but apparently, at least in some regions, people have very, very strong feelings against people of the other party..

Luckily in the end the doctor send a colleague, the Mayer his second man and together with the ones responsible for the transport we reached a needed solution. They were going to buy and send 72 new bottles of oil to the village. End good all good, but I am asking myself: Is this story an example for what is going on all over the country? And does this also happen on a larger scale in the country? For the sake of the future of Nicaragua and the huge amount of people that so desperately need progress, welfare and especially no conflict, I really hope that that is not the case..

 

 

Gallery: 

Comments

Dear Rutger, thank you for sharing your thoughts about this complicated matter. It seems like you have sense the difficulties of the local politics and how this issue, influences and affects our daily life. There are some attitudes and behaviors from our politicians and fanatics from different parties hard to understand. I can understand your frustration, however, we have made some progress in the way we solve political conflicts. We have overcome terrible civil wars; the latest was during the 80's, all Nicaraguan families have very sad memories, even the generation that was born at the end of that decade continue to suffer the consequences of the war, but we are sure that, even though we still have serious political problems, we are not going back to use the guns to face our problems. We have achieved certain level of culture of peace, but we still have to work on that. Please keep writing, I'm sure you have more interesting topics like this to share.
Guus van der Zijden's picture

Clearly, if you rate countries on development you should also look at political transparency and respect. Without transparency on the major topics and without a mutual respect between parties (and voters for that matter) the road to progress and development will transform in a struggle, where it is hard to separate the real issues from childish rivalry.

Thank you Rutger, and yes indeed this is what often happens... corruption and how poor people are kept poor: at voting time they are courted and pleased, but afterward completely forgotten because: not important... the "Bottom Billion" of the world. But there is also much solidarity and assistance by organizations like yours, not all is hopeless, and great you are involved!

Hi Rutger, Interesting to read about the influence/ impact of local politics (and related behavior) on humanitarian work, food aid and daily life in Nicaragua. It gives us a good insight on the challenges that WFP and NGO's face in Nicaragua. Looking forward to your next blog about the Emergency Response operations you have been involved in. Regards, Conny

Hi Rutger, Really nice how you clearly described the example of the influence of political interest on humanitairy aid. If you're working in the Netherlands you can't inmagine those manners in work relations. I'm very curious about the stories you experienced during the fieldtrips!! When is the update coming, am looking forward to it!! Greetz Nienke

Add new comment

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.